Health Sciences > Clinical Research
Title:Assignment of a disputed charge and near reading performance after cataract surgery: a randomized crossover trial
Abstract:Objective: To estimate the effect of assigning a disputed restaurant charge to the reader on the accuracy of near reading after cataract surgery.
Design: Two-period, two-center randomized crossover trial. Adults attending a scheduled postoperative visit read 35 amounts from itemized bills under each of two settlement instructions. A verified charge was returned either to the reader's supplementary allowance or to the restaurant account. Print, viewing distance and time limits were held constant. The prespecified outcome was the number of amounts transcribed exactly.
Results: All 120 randomized participants completed both periods. Mean scores were 27.40 of 35 for the personal account and 23.68 for the restaurant account. The mean paired difference was 3.72 amounts (95% CI 3.14 to 4.30). At the largest print size the difference was two correct readings in 600 presentations. At the smallest size it was 101 in 600. Under concealed settlement instructions, 399 of 600 personal and 395 of 600 restaurant amounts were correct.
Conclusions: Who received the refund affected the reading of the charge. A change in performance equivalent to about three quarters of a chart line occurred within a single postoperative visit and depended on information supplied before the chart appeared.
Submission history
From: Livia Romeri[v1] Sun, 25 Oct 2026 14:37:24 UTC (95 KB)