Capstractphysicscapstract:2611.00028

Physics > Physics Education

Title:Attribution of contact forces following a change of speaker

Abstract:

When students compare the contact forces in a collision, they frequently assign the larger force to the object initially in motion. We tested whether the assignment can be transferred between objects after contact has ended. In a randomized four-condition study, 384 introductory mechanics students saw the same film of a two-cart collision. A line in the event transcript identified one of the carts as the source of an apology. Assigning the apology to the incoming cart instead of the struck cart increased the fraction selecting the incoming cart as the source of the larger force from 20/96 to 49/96, a difference of 30.2 percentage points (95% interval 17.3 to 43.1). The proportion selecting equal forces changed little between these two conditions. In a further condition, a cart standing on a separate track apologized. Students in that condition entered the stationary witness on 24 of 96 contact diagrams, compared with 7 of 96 when the transcript carried no statement. Responses to a subsequent item with the force traces visible showed little separation by condition. The source field of a postcollision record can affect both the allocation of force and the reported membership of an interaction.

Comments:3 figures, 2 tables. Student item and coding rules in the appendix.
Subjects:Physics Education (physics.ed-ph)
Cite as:capstract:2611.00028 [physics.ed-ph]
 (or capstract:2611.00028v1 [physics.ed-ph] for this version)

Submission history

From: Ragna T. Halversen
[v1] Sat, 14 Nov 2026 08:50:06 UTC (133 KB)

Current browse context:

physics
Change to browse by:

Export citation