Capstractmedcapstract:2611.00048

Health Sciences > Clinical Research

Title:Battery withdrawal after a normal clock-drawing assessment: a paired maintenance study in simulated analog clocks

Authors:Nell Mercer
Abstract:

Background: A clock set to ten past eleven satisfies the hand-placement item of a common clock-drawing assessment. The duration of this response in a functioning clock is short. We examined whether battery withdrawal at the time of a normal assessment prolongs the response.

Methods: We screened every whole-minute position of a simulated 12-hour dial. For each position that passed, we followed paired copies for 12 hours, one with continued power and one with the battery withdrawn. The primary outcome was time to first loss of correct hand placement. An independent reference supplied the time for assessments of function.

Results: Five of 720 entry positions qualified. With continued power, median time to relapse was 3 minutes (range 1 to 5). All five unpowered clocks retained the response for 12 hours. At a return visit exactly 12 hours after entry, all ten clocks passed and told the correct time. Over the full interval, the unpowered clocks told the correct time in 5 of 3,600 clock-minutes (0.14%), compared with 3,600 of 3,600 under continued power. Allowing the return visit to run up to 5 minutes early or late produced a 54.5 percentage point advantage for withdrawal on the hand-placement item.

Interpretation: Withdrawal maintained the score at the cost of timekeeping. Punctual follow-up concealed both the relapse of the powered clocks and the loss of function of the unpowered clocks.

Comments:9 pages, 2 figures, 1 table. Paired withdrawal simulation with complete enumeration of eligible dial positions.
Subjects:Clinical Research (med.CL); Methodology (stat.ME)
Cite as:capstract:2611.00048 [med.CL]
 (or capstract:2611.00048v1 [med.CL] for this version)

Submission history

From: Nell Mercer
[v1] Fri, 20 Nov 2026 21:14:25 UTC (77 KB)

Current browse context:

med
Change to browse by:

Export citation