IIntroduction
An object can be observed on our past light cone after it has passed beyond the reach of a signal emitted here today. This distinction is usually described in terms of the particle and event horizons [1]. In an eternally accelerating universe a null ray emitted today can traverse only a finite comoving distance [2]. The standard event-horizon calculation asks about the last signal that one worldline can send to another. It takes no account of whether the recipient can act on that signal and send a new one in reply.
Here we consider exchanges whose timing is set by the arrival of preceding legs. This matters when the initiating station needs a record of an event at the remote endpoint. A successful first crossing is necessary for such a record and can occur even when a second crossing is impossible. A separate issue is whether an otherwise causally accessible reply arrives within the receiver’s passband. The redshift relevant to that calculation is accumulated after the first crossing. The redshift used to locate the remote station, on the other hand, is measured today.
We treat the stations as comoving in a homogeneous, spatially flat background. We first calculate the reachable domains with prescribed local speeds. We then allow the initial carrier to coast, or impose a frequency cut on a returning null signal. In Sec. IV we identify which stages of a delivery record can be verified at the station that opened it.
IIPropagation model
ASequential exchanges
Let and occupy comoving worldlines at radial separation . Station initiates the exchange at cosmic time and the endpoints alternate thereafter. A response carries an identifier specific to the preceding arrival. We require the response to be generated at its endpoint after that arrival. A prearranged transmission does not contain evidence of the arrival, even if the stations know the same schedule [3]. We assume instantaneous processing except when considering a finite turnaround allowance.
For radial propagation write the flat FLRW metric as , with . We define the conformal distance available in proper time on a comoving clock by
A null trajectory between the stations uses of this distance in either direction. If leg proceeds at speed relative to local comoving observers, with held constant during that leg, the maximum separation at time is
The expression is a supremum. A finite arrival time requires . For null trajectories this reduces to . A relay cannot improve the bound for an exchange between specified endpoints, since each leg must traverse at least the radial comoving separation of those endpoints.
A proper time at turnaround consumes a conformal distance . To first order in small turnaround times the loss in range is the sum of these distances divided by , evaluated using the scale factor at each undelayed turnaround. A finite deadline truncates the conformal interval even when all turnarounds are prompt. For all leg counts is measured from the first departure to the final arrival on the common FLRW time coordinate.
BGeodesic first leg
A carrier that maintains constant speed on the first leg has two-leg range with a null response. If both carriers maintain , the range is . These comparisons hold the launch speed fixed.
Alternatively the first carrier can coast on a radial timelike geodesic. Spatial translation symmetry gives , with . Thus its speed decays as , and its range at scale factor is
Let be the remaining conformal distance. The limiting first arrival for a two-leg exchange with a null response satisfies . The left side increases and the right side decreases. With null legs after the first, the corresponding condition is .
CFixed receiving band
Consider two null legs, with the return signal emitted at a fixed frequency at . The receiving station registers the signal if , with . Since , the latest acceptable reception is at . At the limiting separation the two legs satisfy
We assume sufficient received flux for detection inside the band. The model applies to fixed emission and receiver settings. Increasing transmitter power leaves the frequency condition unchanged.
In de Sitter space and Eq. (4) gives . For the fiducial model below we solve in . The distance allowed on the return leg is proportional to , with . This distance increases with since increases on for . The required return distance decreases with . There is then one intersection, and a separate deadline gives the combined boundary .
DBackground model and numerical checks
We adopt with and [4]. Radiation is neglected. The distance evaluations extend back to and the propagation calculations start at . We obtain the redshift label at each boundary by inverting the relation for light received at [5],
For future integrals we set , giving . Adaptive quadrature and bracketed inversion use a nominal tolerance of in dimensionless variables. Tightening it by a factor of ten in the geodesic calculation changes the quoted radii by less than in relative terms. Direct quadrature in agrees with the value of to the same precision. In the de Sitter limit we recover the closed form solution of Eq. (4) and the geodesic distance
IIIReachable domains
ANull propagation
The present-day fiducial event horizon is 5.114 Gpc. Two exchanges initiated today at different separations are shown in Fig. 1. A target observed at is at Gpc. A null signal sent today arrives after 18.90 Gyr of comoving proper time. The reply remains outside the causal past of station for all future times.
The uniform comoving volume available to an -leg null exchange is times the one-leg volume. This ratio is independent of the expansion law as long as there is a finite event horizon, the stations are comoving, and both volumes are inside the sample. As a geometric control, Table I uses a catalog with constant comoving density truncated at , corresponding to 6.506 Gpc. Of its addresses 48.56% are within the one-leg volume. Only 6.07% admit a round trip. An observed catalog would require weights for selection and source evolution.
| Number of legs | (Gpc) | Catalog volume (%) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 5.114 | 1.869 | 48.56 |
| 2 | 2.557 | 0.691 | 6.07 |
| 3 | 1.705 | 0.428 | 1.80 |
| 4 | 1.278 | 0.311 | 0.76 |
Varying between 0.308 and 0.322 moves the two-leg boundary from 2.547 to 2.566 Gpc and its redshift from 0.685 to 0.697. Varying by moves the distance by about 0.019 Gpc. The redshift stays fixed at constant because the past and future distances in the calculation both scale as . The sensitivities vary one parameter at a time by its Planck marginal error.
BDependence on transport and deadline
For a maintained launch speed of , changing only the second leg to a null signal increases the two-leg radius by a factor of 1.82, corresponding to a factor of 6.01 in volume Table II. A geodesic first leg and a null second leg reach 0.248 Gpc at the same launch speed. This is within 0.001 Gpc of the geodesic one-leg range. Most of the loss in reach comes from redshifting of the carrier’s momentum.
| One leg, maintained | One leg, geodesic | Two maintained | Maintained and null | Geodesic and null | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0.10 | 0.5114 | 0.2488 | 0.2557 | 0.4649 | 0.2483 |
| 0.50 | 2.5568 | 1.3332 | 1.2784 | 1.7045 | 1.2496 |
| 0.90 | 4.6023 | 3.1505 | 2.3011 | 2.4223 | 2.2873 |
| 1.00 | 5.1136 | 5.1136 | 2.5568 | 2.5568 | 2.5568 |
The near overlap of two curves in panel (a) of Fig. 2 can be understood from the de Sitter limit. Substitution in Eq. (6) gives at , so a geodesic carrier with a null response has exactly the same reach as two constant-speed carriers, . For a positive matter density define . The integrand decreases with , hence is concave and in the interior. At a fixed remaining fraction of the light budget the scale factor is larger than in de Sitter space because . A geodesic carrier is therefore slower at fixed than in de Sitter space at the same launch speed. Its normalized distance is the integral of its speed in units of from to 1. The crossing with the straight line representing the reach of the response consequently lies below for every .
With null transport, a deadline of 10 Gyr permits travel over 44.23% of the infinite-time radius. The two-leg redshift threshold is then 0.272, rising to 0.546 for a deadline of 30 Gyr. The corresponding three-leg threshold at 30 Gyr is 0.344 Fig. 2. Reaching 90% or 99% of the radius takes 40.1 or 80.4 Gyr, respectively, for any fixed number of legs. At large , , with . The waiting time for a target a distance inside the limiting radius thus grows as up to an additive constant.
CFrequency selection
The boundary for a fixed detector band is shown in Fig. 3. With the fiducial two-leg radius is 1.690 Gpc, giving . The radius is 66.1% of its unfiltered value and the volume is 28.9%. At the radius is 2.188 Gpc and the volume fraction is 62.6%. For the frequency limit is comparable to the infinite-time radius of a third unfiltered leg.
IVApplication to refused shipments
Suppose an addressee refuses an article at receiving office , which dispatches it back to the return address at . The sender’s signature at records delivery. Furnishing it to requires a second transit. Conveying the office’s countersignature to requires a third. Terrestrial mail standards distinguish return of a refused item, obtaining a signature on certain classes of return mail, and furnishing proof of delivery [6, 7]. The countersignature is an additional service condition.
For a refusal processed today, the shell admits return of the item but precludes the return of a signature even with ideal null transport. It contains seven eighths of the one-leg comoving volume. In this shell the receiving office can observe the same empty signature field whether or not the sender has taken possession. Recording that field as sender refusal would misclassify every completed delivery in the shell. The station that opened the record can instead select the level of evidence it will require based on the original sender’s address. That information is available at the time of refusal.
The band calculation gives a second restriction for an office that uses fixed-frequency electronic proof of delivery. At the office can receive a null signature in 24.97 Gyr, within a 30 Gyr retention period. However, the received frequency is lower than the emitted frequency by a factor of 2.641. For a receiver with a cutoff at half the emission frequency, the signal arrives below the cutoff. Either a wider band or a change in emission frequency can make this example eligible. No such changes make an unfiltered signature from arrive.
A 30 day hold for obtaining a signature changes the ideal two-leg distance by about 0.006 pc. At the boundary the turnaround is at , so the conformal time consumed by a local handling interval is less than today. The frequency cut changes the distance by 0.867 Gpc at . For the modeled service, the acceptance range is sensitive to the choice of receipt channel even when the handling interval is immaterial.
VDiscussion
The cut at finite distance depends on the continuation of accelerated expansion. As a comparison, suppose the expansion history is identical to the fiducial model through , and the energy in the vacuum component subsequently dilutes as pressureless matter. The density is continuous across the transition. In the matter-dominated future , so the future null distance diverges. Any finite null exchange can then be completed given enough time, despite identical distances on today’s past light cone. The reach of a coasting carrier remains finite in the same model because its speed supplies another factor of to the range integrand.
We neglect peculiar motion, lensing, signal attenuation and the lifetime of stations. A relay can establish custody at its own location. Proof of receipt at the original address requires a signal from that address. The terrestrial provision to keep the return-receipt card attached to certain undeliverable articles puts both records at the original address. In the one-leg shell, the refusing office can close a delivered case only if its rules accept a receipt held by the sender.
Data availability
The results use deterministic quadrature. The background parameters, propagation law and sample selection are specified in Sec. II. The volume fractions are obtained by integrating a constant comoving density.
- [1]T. M. Davis and C. H. Lineweaver, Publ. Astron. Soc. Aust. 21, 97 (2004).
- [2]L. M. Krauss and G. D. Starkman, Astrophys. J. 531, 22 (2000).
- [3]J. Y. Halpern and Y. Moses, J. ACM 37, 549 (1990).
- [4]Planck Collaboration, Astron. Astrophys. 641, A6 (2020).
- [5]D. W. Hogg, Distance Measures in Cosmology, arXiv:astro-ph/9905116 (1999).
- [6]United States Postal Service, Domestic Mail Manual, Sect. 507.1.8: Returning Mail, Postal Explorer (2026a).
- [7]United States Postal Service, Domestic Mail Manual, Sect. 503.6: Return Receipt, Postal Explorer (2026b).