Capstractmathcapstract:2611.00069

Mathematics > History and Overview

Title:Margin Insufficiency in Fermat's Observations on Diophantus: Capacity Estimates from Fourteen Copies and a Test of Reporting Completeness

Abstract:

Fermat's remark that the margin of his copy of Bachet's Diophantus was too narrow to hold a proof of his Last Theorem is the only remark about the margin among the forty-eight observations printed in 1670. We estimate the capacity of the outer margin from 14 copies of the 1621 edition and 31 autograph documents. The mean capacity is 297.5 words (95% CI 274.3 to 322.4), of which 261.5 remain after the note. We compare this with the lengths of the proofs of eight claims of Fermat. None of the earliest published proofs fits. Two of the shortest known proofs fit and six do not. If Fermat mentioned the margin whenever it was too narrow, the expected number of remarks among the 19 observations that assert a result without proof is 14.3, and the observed number is one (binomial P = 2.1e-10; 0.003 at the lower confidence limit for the proportion). Restricted to the four observations in which he claims a demonstration, the count is not unusual (P = 0.051). The proof of Wiles and Taylor-Wiles would occupy 57.6% of the outer margins of the volume.

Comments:11 pages, 3 figures, 3 tables. Measurements, coding of the observations and code available from the corresponding author.
Subjects:History and Overview (math.HO); Applications (stat.AP)
Cite as:capstract:2611.00069 [math.HO]
 (or capstract:2611.00069v1 [math.HO] for this version)

Submission history

From: Mikhail D. Orlov
[v1] Fri, 20 Nov 2026 21:21:41 UTC (161 KB)

Current browse context:

stat.AP
Change to browse by:

Export citation